18 August 2016
CO16209 | Two Years Under Jokowi – President’s Special Relationship with Luhut Panjaitan
RSIS Commentary is a platform to provide timely and, where appropriate, policy-relevant commentary and analysis of topical and contemporary issues. The authors’ views are their own and do not represent the official position of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), NTU. These commentaries may be reproduced with prior permission from RSIS and due credit to the author(s) and RSIS. Please email to Editor RSIS Commentary at [email protected].
Synopsis
Without networks within the military, and having no effective power over the political parties, President Joko Widodo (Jokowi) has been constrained in his political manoeuvres. He has, however, installed strong, well-networked, and experienced retired army generals, notably Luhut Binsar Panjaitan, as his aides. Is Jokowi dependent on him?
Commentary
JOKO WIDODO, Indonesia’s seventh president, has installed retired army generals to important civilian posts as coordinating ministers, defence minister, and head of state intelligence. The inclusion of a considerable number of former military officers in his administration has been Jokowi’s way to balance the influence of the oligarchs that supported him during his presidential campaign.
Arguably, one of the most significant appointments that Jokowi has made is the appointment of Luhut Binsar Panjaitan, a former Suharto era four-star special forces general, to help him in consolidating power.
Hand of the King
Luhut’s appointment was important for Jokowi for several reasons. Other than providing a crucial channel to the military, Luhut has served to enforce some measure of discipline in the Cabinet. His presence is important for Jokowi to help him consolidate power. Some ministers have mocked Jokowi’s inability to rule, which showed their lack of respect for the President. In addressing political incoherence within Jokowi’s Cabinet, Luhut remarked that it is forbidden for state institutions, ministers, or agencies to contradict the President.
Further, Luhut asserted that ministers or state agencies are required to keep the president informed before making public statements. Indeed, it is peculiar within the context of a decentralised and democratic state, but Jokowi justified these dispositions as a way to unify differing voices and interests within his Cabinet.
Luhut is also important to help him balance the various oligarchic interests. One interesting strategy was Luhut’s endorsement last year of Rizal Ramli as the Coordinating Minister of Maritime Affairs. The reputation of Rizal Ramli as a controversial critic has preceded him, and Jokowi’s decision to position him in a very strategic and central ministry, has left many wondering whether it was a deliberate strategy against the oligarchs.
Since he assumed the position, Rizal Ramli has devoted significant attention criticising projects that are related to the interests of several oligarchs. The high profile feuds included his public attack of Vice President Jusuf Kalla in August 2015, over the 35,000 megawatt electrical generator project that Kalla was proposing. Rizal Ramli also publicly attacked Sudirman Said, who was closely associated with Kalla, over the Freeport fiasco and the Masela gas field controversies. Although Sudirman Said and Rizal Ramli were dismissed in the last reshuffle, it provided Jokowi the opportunity to bring in a professional, Arcandra Tahar, to replace Sudirman Said, although the new minister was himself swiftly replaced after he was found to possess a US passport. Following this, Jokowi entrusted Luhut to temporarily cover Arcandra’s position.
Political Conflict
Luhut’s strong connection with Setya Novanto, the newly appointed leader of the Functional Groups Party (Golkar), also increased leverage for Jokowi as he has an option to switch from the Indonesian Democratic Party – Struggle (PDI-P) led by Megawati Sukarnoputri to Golkar for the next presidential election. Setya was previously Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR). He however resigned after the controversy surrounding the renewal of the contract with an affiliate of US-based Freeport-McMoRan that operates the world’s largest gold mine and third-largest copper mine. Setya was heard on tape asking for a share in a power plant in Papua in return for his role to persuade Jokowi and Luhut, his trusted adviser, to extend the Freeport contract.
Despite all these high-profile conflicts, Setya, with the strong endorsement of Luhut, was elected as the head of one of the most prominent political parties in Indonesia – Golkar – during its recent election. Although the election process during Golkar’s convention was allegedly mired in money politics, Setya’s election was applauded by the President. In return, Setya overturned Golkar’s neutral position to be one of Jokowi’s coalition supporters, adding a significant boost to Jokowi’s position.
Balancing Act
Luhut’s powerful role in the Jokowi administration signified the fundamental benefits gained by the President to solidify his political powerbase. This development, however, has aroused questions over Jokowi’s political independence.
Jokowi’s latest decision to move Luhut to a less prestigious position, as the Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs, has been seen by many as a sign of Jokowi’s growing wariness of Luhut’s overt influence in Cabinet. Hence they see this as Jokowi’s display of power that he is still the man in charge of his administration.
Further, although the appointment of Luhut appeared to have diluted the overwhelming control that PDI-P had over him, Jokowi did not abandon his relations with his own party. In fact this relationship is important to deter Luhut’s growing influence in his Cabinet. In the beginning, Jokowi intended to make Luhut a “super minister” by giving him dual positions as the Presidential Chief of Staff and Coordinating Minister of Politics, Law, and Security. However, the position of Chief of Staff was later given to Teten Masduki, an Indonesian anti-corruption activist, who has warm relations with Megawati. Jokowi appointed Pramono Anung, Megawati’s trusted man, as Cabinet Secretary so that Anung could bridge communication with the party.
This balancing act has shown that while Luhut’s presence is pivotal, it is essential for Jokowi to stay loyal to PDI-P. This will continue over the course of his administration, unless he is able to form his own party in the next election.
About the Author
Emirza Adi Syailendra is a Research Analyst in the Indonesia Programme of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University. This is part of a series on the Jokowi presidency.
Last updated on 18/08/2016
RSIS Commentary is a platform to provide timely and, where appropriate, policy-relevant commentary and analysis of topical and contemporary issues. The authors’ views are their own and do not represent the official position of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies (RSIS), NTU. These commentaries may be reproduced with prior permission from RSIS and due credit to the author(s) and RSIS. Please email to Editor RSIS Commentary at [email protected].
Synopsis
Without networks within the military, and having no effective power over the political parties, President Joko Widodo (Jokowi) has been constrained in his political manoeuvres. He has, however, installed strong, well-networked, and experienced retired army generals, notably Luhut Binsar Panjaitan, as his aides. Is Jokowi dependent on him?
Commentary
JOKO WIDODO, Indonesia’s seventh president, has installed retired army generals to important civilian posts as coordinating ministers, defence minister, and head of state intelligence. The inclusion of a considerable number of former military officers in his administration has been Jokowi’s way to balance the influence of the oligarchs that supported him during his presidential campaign.
Arguably, one of the most significant appointments that Jokowi has made is the appointment of Luhut Binsar Panjaitan, a former Suharto era four-star special forces general, to help him in consolidating power.
Hand of the King
Luhut’s appointment was important for Jokowi for several reasons. Other than providing a crucial channel to the military, Luhut has served to enforce some measure of discipline in the Cabinet. His presence is important for Jokowi to help him consolidate power. Some ministers have mocked Jokowi’s inability to rule, which showed their lack of respect for the President. In addressing political incoherence within Jokowi’s Cabinet, Luhut remarked that it is forbidden for state institutions, ministers, or agencies to contradict the President.
Further, Luhut asserted that ministers or state agencies are required to keep the president informed before making public statements. Indeed, it is peculiar within the context of a decentralised and democratic state, but Jokowi justified these dispositions as a way to unify differing voices and interests within his Cabinet.
Luhut is also important to help him balance the various oligarchic interests. One interesting strategy was Luhut’s endorsement last year of Rizal Ramli as the Coordinating Minister of Maritime Affairs. The reputation of Rizal Ramli as a controversial critic has preceded him, and Jokowi’s decision to position him in a very strategic and central ministry, has left many wondering whether it was a deliberate strategy against the oligarchs.
Since he assumed the position, Rizal Ramli has devoted significant attention criticising projects that are related to the interests of several oligarchs. The high profile feuds included his public attack of Vice President Jusuf Kalla in August 2015, over the 35,000 megawatt electrical generator project that Kalla was proposing. Rizal Ramli also publicly attacked Sudirman Said, who was closely associated with Kalla, over the Freeport fiasco and the Masela gas field controversies. Although Sudirman Said and Rizal Ramli were dismissed in the last reshuffle, it provided Jokowi the opportunity to bring in a professional, Arcandra Tahar, to replace Sudirman Said, although the new minister was himself swiftly replaced after he was found to possess a US passport. Following this, Jokowi entrusted Luhut to temporarily cover Arcandra’s position.
Political Conflict
Luhut’s strong connection with Setya Novanto, the newly appointed leader of the Functional Groups Party (Golkar), also increased leverage for Jokowi as he has an option to switch from the Indonesian Democratic Party – Struggle (PDI-P) led by Megawati Sukarnoputri to Golkar for the next presidential election. Setya was previously Speaker of the House of Representatives (DPR). He however resigned after the controversy surrounding the renewal of the contract with an affiliate of US-based Freeport-McMoRan that operates the world’s largest gold mine and third-largest copper mine. Setya was heard on tape asking for a share in a power plant in Papua in return for his role to persuade Jokowi and Luhut, his trusted adviser, to extend the Freeport contract.
Despite all these high-profile conflicts, Setya, with the strong endorsement of Luhut, was elected as the head of one of the most prominent political parties in Indonesia – Golkar – during its recent election. Although the election process during Golkar’s convention was allegedly mired in money politics, Setya’s election was applauded by the President. In return, Setya overturned Golkar’s neutral position to be one of Jokowi’s coalition supporters, adding a significant boost to Jokowi’s position.
Balancing Act
Luhut’s powerful role in the Jokowi administration signified the fundamental benefits gained by the President to solidify his political powerbase. This development, however, has aroused questions over Jokowi’s political independence.
Jokowi’s latest decision to move Luhut to a less prestigious position, as the Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs, has been seen by many as a sign of Jokowi’s growing wariness of Luhut’s overt influence in Cabinet. Hence they see this as Jokowi’s display of power that he is still the man in charge of his administration.
Further, although the appointment of Luhut appeared to have diluted the overwhelming control that PDI-P had over him, Jokowi did not abandon his relations with his own party. In fact this relationship is important to deter Luhut’s growing influence in his Cabinet. In the beginning, Jokowi intended to make Luhut a “super minister” by giving him dual positions as the Presidential Chief of Staff and Coordinating Minister of Politics, Law, and Security. However, the position of Chief of Staff was later given to Teten Masduki, an Indonesian anti-corruption activist, who has warm relations with Megawati. Jokowi appointed Pramono Anung, Megawati’s trusted man, as Cabinet Secretary so that Anung could bridge communication with the party.
This balancing act has shown that while Luhut’s presence is pivotal, it is essential for Jokowi to stay loyal to PDI-P. This will continue over the course of his administration, unless he is able to form his own party in the next election.
About the Author
Emirza Adi Syailendra is a Research Analyst in the Indonesia Programme of the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University. This is part of a series on the Jokowi presidency.
Last updated on 18/08/2016
